Structured Settlement vs Annuity: What is the difference between a structured settlement and an annuity? Discover the key differences, pros, cons, and expert insights in this detailed, easy-to-understand guide.
What Is the Difference Between a Structured Settlement and an Annuity?
Have you ever wondered why two financial products sound the same but work totally differently?
It’s a common question: What’s the difference between a structured settlement and an annuity? They both give steady income over time. But they work, come from, and are used for in different ways.
If you’re dealing with a legal case, personal injury claim, or thinking about long-term financial planning, understanding these two tools can help you make smart choices. Don’t worry—we’ll break it down in plain English. Let’s dive in!
What Is a Structured Settlement?
A structured settlement is a legal agreement that pays out money from a lawsuit over time instead of one big chunk.
✅ Here’s how it works:
- You win or settle a personal injury or wrongful death lawsuit.
- Instead of getting one huge payment, the money is set up to come in regular payments—monthly, annually, or whatever you agree.
- It’s tax-free if it’s from a personal injury case.
- Payments come from a purchased annuity, usually from a life insurance company.
👉 It’s like turning a court win into a long-term paycheck.
What Is an Annuity?
An annuity is a financial product you buy (usually from an insurance company) to provide steady income, usually after retirement.
✅ How an annuity works:
- You give an insurance company a lump sum or pay over time.
- They promise to pay you regular income for a period—or the rest of your life.
- You can buy one yourself (not tied to a lawsuit).
- There are many types: immediate, deferred, fixed, variable, and indexed.
👉 Think of it as a personal pension you set up for yourself.
Structured Settlement vs Annuity: Key Differences
Here’s a quick overview of how they stack up side by side:
| Feature | Structured Settlement | Annuity |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Court case (like a personal injury) | Bought from insurance companies |
| Who sets it up? | Usually the defendant’s insurance company | You (or your financial advisor) |
| Tax treatment | Tax-free (in injury cases) | May be taxed depending on the type |
| Flexibility | Not flexible—payment terms are fixed | Some offer flexible payout options |
| Control | Set by court and insurance company | You control the purchase and options |
| Purpose | Replace income after an injury or legal judgment | Retirement income, long-term savings, investment growth |
Who Uses Structured Settlements?
Structured settlements are for people who:
- Win a personal injury lawsuit
- Settle a medical malpractice case
- Get money for wrongful death claims
💡 They help ensure long-term financial stability. This is important when someone can’t work because of an injury.
Who Buys Annuities?
Annuities are bought by:
- Retirees wanting steady income
- People planning for financial security later in life
- Individuals seeking guaranteed returns with less risk
💡 Annuities are like your own private pension.
Can You Sell a Structured Settlement?
Yes, but it’s not simple.
You can sell all or part of your future payments to a factoring company. But:
- You need court approval.
- You might get less than the full value of your payments.
- It’s often a last resort.
🧠 Quote to remember:
“A structured settlement isn’t just a paycheck—it’s a financial lifeline. Be careful before you trade it away.”
Can You Cash Out an Annuity?
Yes, most annuities let you:
- Withdraw a portion (usually up to 10%) annually without penalty
- Cancel or “surrender” the contract (but fees may apply)
- Convert it to regular income through annuitization
🔔 Watch out for surrender charges if you take money out too early.
Tax Differences Between the Two
Taxes can be tricky, but here’s the basic idea:
| Tax Factor | Structured Settlement | Annuity |
|---|---|---|
| Personal Injury Payout | Tax-free | N/A |
| Interest Earnings | Not taxed (in most cases) | Taxed as income |
| Withdrawals | Not applicable | May face penalties if taken early |
💸 If taxes stress you out, a structured settlement from a lawsuit is usually the safer bet.
Are Annuities Safer Than Structured Settlements?
Both are pretty safe. They’re backed by insurance companies, not banks.
But there’s a catch:
- Structured settlements are locked in. No changes.
- Annuities can have more options, but they also come with fees and fine print.
Bottom line? Structured settlements are safer in the short term. Annuities offer more control and possible growth.
Types of Annuities (And Why It Matters)
All annuities aren’t the same. Here’s a quick look:
| Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Fixed Annuity | Pays a guaranteed amount |
| Variable Annuity | Linked to the stock market—can grow or shrink |
| Indexed Annuity | Tied to an index like the S&P 500 |
| Immediate Annuity | Starts paying income right away |
| Deferred Annuity | Pays later (often used for retirement) |
🎯 If you like guarantees, go fixed. If you like the chance to grow, go variable.
Which One’s Right for You?
It depends on your situation:
- Just won a lawsuit? A structured settlement might be the best choice.
- Planning for retirement? An annuity could offer peace of mind.
- Need flexibility? Annuities give more control.
- Want guaranteed, tax-free payments? Structured settlements are the way to go.
Pros and Cons of Structured Settlements
Pros:
- Tax-free income
- Guaranteed payments
- No investment risk
Cons:
- No flexibility
- Hard to access lump sums
- Requires court involvement to sell
Pros and Cons of Annuities
Pros:
- Flexible options
- Guaranteed income
- Can plan around retirement
Cons:
- Can be taxed
- Early withdrawal fees
- Complexity (lots of fine print!)
⚖️ Structured Settlement vs. Annuity
| Feature | Structured Settlement | Annuity |
|---|---|---|
| Court-Involved | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Purchased Voluntarily | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Tax-Free | ✅ Usually | ❌ Not always |
| Guaranteed Payments | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes (in fixed types) |
| Flexibility | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Investment Growth | ❌ No | ✅ Possible |
🎯 Final Thoughts
So, what’s the difference between a structured settlement and an annuity? It really comes down to purpose and control.
- Structured settlements are court-created tools to protect people who need steady, safe income after a life-changing event.
- Annuities are something you choose, giving you flexibility, investment options, and personalized retirement income.
Both are powerful financial tools—but they serve different goals. Knowing the difference can help you plan smarter, protect your future, and feel more confident about where your money’s going.
🤔 Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can I convert a structured settlement into an annuity?
No, but a structured settlement is funded by an annuity. You can’t turn one into the other once set up.
2. Are annuities a good investment for everyone?
Not always. They’re great for long-term income, but not ideal if you need quick access or high returns.
3. Is it legal to sell a structured settlement?
Yes—but you need court approval. And you usually get less than it’s worth in the long run.
4. Can I buy a structured settlement myself?
Nope. Structured settlements are court-awarded. You can only buy an annuity.
5. What happens to my annuity if I die?
It depends on your contract. Some go to your beneficiary. Others stop paying after your death.
Sources: